• Type:
  • Genre:
  • Duration:
  • Average Rating:

Disney+

Review: Raya and the Last Dragon

Raya and the Last Dragon (2021)

review | Raya and the Last Dragon

recent reviews

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

Disney rewrites the princess playbook with this effort to play to the girl-power crowd

by John Sciacca
March 8, 2021

Raya features the classic elements of Disney princess fairy tales: A girl loses her family and is forced to grow and trust in herself to solve some major problem, having to enlist others along the way to aid in her struggle. She even passes many of the “princess tests” from Ralph Breaks the Internet. What kind of princess are you? Do you have magic hair? (No.) Magic hands? (No.) Do animals talk to you? (Kind of.) Were you poisoned? (No, but it’s mentioned.) Cursed? (There is a curse on the land.) Kidnapped or enslaved? (No.) Made a deal with an underwater sea witch where she took your voice in exchange for a pair of human legs? (Ummm, no.) Have you ever had true love’s kiss? (Big no.) Do you have daddy issues? (Yep.) Don’t even have a mom. (Yep.) Do people assume all your problems got solved because a big strong man showed up? (A big strong man does join her quest and helps, but he doesn’t solve her problems.)” Also, put a checkmark in the “stare at important water” category.

But Raya is also definitely not your typical Disney princess or princess film as Raya (voiced by Kelly Marie Tran) is indisputably Disney’s most bad-ass, girl-power princess ever, featuring a lot of attitude and swagger. She never backs down from a fight and engages in various forms of hand-to-hand combat throughout. In fact, Raya reminded me of the live-action Mulan remake, including the fact that there’s no singing. (Another break for your typical Disney princess.) 

The story takes place in the once prosperous land of Kumandra, where dragons co-exist with humans and bring water, rain, and peace to the land. Evil spirits called the Druun come, turning all humans to stone, and the dragons sacrifice themselves in order to save humanity, placing all of their spirits into a single magic gem. A power struggle to possess the gem causes the once peaceful land to split into five tribes: Fang, Heart, Tail, Spine, and Talon. 

After 500 years, Raya’s dad, Chief Benja (Daniel Dae Kim) of the Heart tribe, holder of the gem, tries to reunite the tribes but the Dragon gem is broken into five pieces, with each tribe taking a piece and causing the Druun to return and turning many to stone. 

Raya escapes, and armed with her father’s sword and riding atop her combination pill bug/armadillo/hedgehog creature Tuk Tuk (Alan Tudyk), she embarks on a quest to find Sisu (Awkwafina), who is said to be the last surviving dragon. With hopes of ridding the Druun once and for all and bringing her father back, Raya’s quest leads her to all of the villages, which have their own visual style, and have Indiana Jones-like elements to complete.

Disney animation is top-notch so the fantastic visuals shouldn’t come as any surprise. There are amazing levels of detail in closeups, with rich texture in fabric, wood, stone, and hair. Water—which plays an important role in the film—also looks photo-realistic, with incredible movement and reflection. Closeups of Sisu in human form reveal strands of hair that seem to be individually colored in her purple-pink-blue-white ombre style. And the care the animators took in the way fabric drapes and moves on characters has lifelike realism. The computer animation style is different from Pixar’s, but equally top-shelf

HDR provides beautiful depth, highlights, shadow detail, and rich colors, especially when viewed on a Dolby Vision-capable display. The magic Dragon gem has a real Arkenstone quality, internally lit by shifting, glowing, sparkling shafts of light, and the Talon village at night is especially gorgeous, glowing with rich, warm, and vibrant lighting and lamps that leaps from the screen. Raya features a frequently bright and saturated color palette that is visually arresting and a treat to look at.

Having watched Raya twice—once on my 115-inch JVC 4K projector and again on a 65-inch Sony 4K LED—I did notice that backgrounds frequently have a bit of a grainy/noisy/cloudy haze. As this is computer animation, it’s obvious it isn’t actually grain or noise, so it must be a stylistic choice the animators took to keep the world from appearing too perfect. They also frequently chose to use “portrait mode” styling on closeups, where objects not close up in frame are defocused. 

The soundtrack was pretty lackluster—unfortunately, a common complaint with many recent Disney transfers. Even played back at reference volume on my Marantz processor, dynamics were heavily compressed and rarely delivered any impact. It wasn’t until the climax that it seemed like the subwoofers really kicked in, and even then, they were restrained and didn’t deliver the impact I expected. Whether this was a shortcoming of the film itself or my Apple 4K TV, I can’t say, but I was disappointed with the sonics. However, judging by the quality of the song “Lead the Way” (performed by Aiko) played over the end credits with a lot more dimension, dynamics, and space, I feel like it is the mix itself. There are some atmospheric surround effects—particularly at the very beginning and end—such as wind, rain, forest sounds, and echoes, and the score is expanded across the front of the room, but primarily this is a front-channel-centric mix that feels like it is designed to be listened to through a TV or soundbar.

Raya and the Last Dragon looks gorgeous, and the voice acting—especially the always likable Awkafina, who brings the right level of humor and quirkiness to Sisu—is on point. While the lack of any songs and intense scenes might limit its replay value for younger viewers, it’s an entertaining film that will appeal to many viewers, as attested to by its 95% Rotten Tomatoes critics’ rating and 85% audience score. I have two daughters—ages 14 and almost five—so for us, a movie night where we can all get together and enjoy a new Disney animated film was an easy yes. 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | HDR provides beautiful depth, highlights, shadow detail, and rich colors, especially when viewed on a Dolby Vision-capable display

SOUND | The soundtrack is lackluster. Even played back at reference volume on a Marantz processor, dynamics were heavily compressed and rarely delivered any impact.

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Luca

Luca (2021)

review | Luca

The least satisfying Pixar film since The Good Dinosaur does turn out to be more kid-friendly than Soul

by John Sciacca
June 21, 2021

When I was in high school, my favorite band was the Talking Heads, and I had this weird love-hate anxiety when they would release a new album and I would go to listen to it for the first time. Would I love it because I actually loved it, or would I make myself say I loved it because it was from the Heads, or would lead singer David Byrne have taken them off on some new musical direction that meant I actually didn’t love it and I couldn’t even bring myself to lie that I did? That’s a bit how I feel about a new film from Pixar.

Pixar Animation is about one of the surest bets around when it comes to delivering solid entertainment. And I don’t mean only in animated titles, but in just great movies in general. While I used to get a bit concerned because Pixar trailers used to seem so generic and uninteresting—always fearing, “Well, this is the one where Pixar finally misses the mark”—I’ve come to realize the company just doesn’t produce great trailers, often because their stories are so layered you can’t really hope to encapsulate the whole spirit in a one-to-two-minute spot. 

So, even though I wasn’t overly excited by the trailers for Luca, the studio’s 24th film, which premiered on Disney+ this past Thursday (June 18), I wasn’t overly concerned. But, I’m sad to say, I think this might be the company’s weakest film to date, certainly rivaling 2015’s The Good Dinosaur, which is widely considered the worst film in the company’s canon. 

It’s not that Luca is bad by any means; in fact, it might even be a good movie. It’s just that it’s not a great one, and that is the nearly impossible situation Pixar has placed on itself after delivering one great film after another that anything less than a home run is considered disappointing. 

The letdown is even more compounded by the fact that Luca follows Soul, the studio’s most adult and ambitious title to date that was so full of, well, soul. Soul took on incredibly complex and heavy issues and had such fantastic depth that the light and saccharine sweetness of Luca just seems all the emptier because of it.

Luca is just . . . simple. It’s hard to really care too deeply about its characters because the story doesn’t give us enough to care about them. Sure, there are tons of metaphors and parallels you can draw. The characters’ goal is to win a race that will give them enough money to buy a Vespa, which the film literally tells us is freedom—the freedom to get out and see the world beyond your four walls, which is especially exciting for Luca Paguro (voiced by Jacob Tremblay), who has lived a very sheltered and protected life. (“I never go anywhere. Just dream about it.”) The characters are also hiding the secret about what they really are (sea monsters), looking to fit in and gain acceptance from the small Italian city of Portorosso which hates/fears what they really are. And if you want to draw a parallel to the LGBTQ community here, well, it doesn’t take much of a stretch. 

The film takes place around the ‘50s and ‘60s on the Italian Riviera, where sea monster Luca spends his days herding fish like a shepherd. One day while out swimming, he meets Alberto Scorfano (Jack Dylan Grazer), who shows him that when dry on land, they transform into human form. Alberto pushes Luca beyond his comfort zone until one day Luca’s parents (voiced by Maya Rudolph and Jim Gaffigan) discover what he’s been doing and threaten to send him away to the deep to live with his bizarre—and semi-translucent—Uncle Ugo (Sacha Baron Cohen). 

Luca and Alberto swim over to the city of Portorusso, where they attempt to blend in with the “land monsters” and fulfill their dream of getting a Vespa. They befriend Giulia (Emma Berman) whose dad Massimo (Marco Barricelli) happens to be a major fisherman and sea-monster hunter. The film builds to the Portorusso Cup Triathlon, a race where the winner gets a trophy and prize money, with the boys in constant fear of getting wet and revealing their secret.

One thing you can’t fault Pixar on is the technical presentation, as Luca just looks gorgeous. I watched it the first time on my 4K projector in HDR10 and then again on a new Sony OLED in Dolby Vision and the colors are just straight-up eye candy throughout. The animation is definitely more cartoony, not having that hyper-realistic look found in some of Pixar’s other films (e.g.., the jazz-club scene in Soul). Even still, the colors burst off the screen and this make your video display pop.

Water is notoriously difficult to animate and render, but here it looks fantastic. Also, even through Disney+ streaming (via my Apple TV), I didn’t notice any banding issues as the sunlight filtered from the surface down through various layers, colors, and shades of the ocean— something that looked especially natural on the OLED with Dolby Vision. One scene had water crashing into a rocky shoreline with clear and individual detail to each rock, with the foam, froth, and bubbles in the water incredibly detailed. There are also subtle details like the different shades of color in the sand as water laps in and out. And there’s super-fine detail in clothing, letting you clearly see the differences in fabric texture, patterns, and weaves worn by characters.

Much of Luca takes place in daytime in the town of Portorosso, with brilliant sun shining in piercing blue skies; bright, emerald grasses; and multi-colored buildings, or the warm, golden-orange hues as the sun sets. It all looks gorgeous. 

Kind of like the story itself, Luca’s audio mix was just satisfactory. Dialogue is well rendered primarily in the center channel (though it does occasionally follow characters as they move off screen), making it clear and intelligible, but even though it’s a Dolby Atmos mix, it was very subtle and reserved.

Italian songs of the era are sprinkled throughout, and they get some room across the front channels and a bit up into the overheads, but the rest of the effects are pretty sparse. There were some instances of the sounds of boats passing overhead or a harpoon thrown that passes by but I didn’t find the mix dynamic at all. (Again, whether this was a streaming issue or an Apple TV issue, I can’t say.) 

I did notice that the soundfield opened up a bit as Luca left the water and went onto dry land. It wasn’t through a big use of audio, but rather just the sonic sense that the room had expanded with sounds of gentle wind, rustling leaves, and birds that let you know you are up in the human world.

Is Luca worth seeing? For Disney+ subscribers, I’d say definitely. If nothing else, it’s beautiful to look at. And, it’s not that it’s a bad film. In fact, you could easily say that while Soul was a Pixar title made for adults, Luca sets its sights squarely on a younger audience, with a coming-of-age story about friendship, acceptance, childhood dreams, and overcoming fears that never gets too deep or strays too far from safety and cuteness that kids will be drawn to. And if it came from any other studio (well, with the exception of Disney Animation, Pixar’s parent company), it would likely be heralded as a triumph. It’s just that Pixar has come to make us expect so much more.  

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | Luca looks gorgeous. The colors burst off the screen and will make your video display pop.

SOUND | The audio is just satisfactory. There are some instances of the sounds of boats passing overhead or a harpoon thrown that passes by, but the mix isn’t dynamic at all. 

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Eternals

Eternals (2021)

review | Eternals

the MCU on Cineluxe

recent articles

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

Too long and overpopulated with unfamiliar characters, the lowest-rated MCU entry to date is a slog even for die-hard Marvel fans

by John Sciacca
January 14, 2022

Back when I was a club golf professional, we had a TV in the pro shop where we would watch whatever tournament was on. This was during the time Tiger Woods turned professional and started his dominating run on the PGA Tour. Every week, we’d have these tournaments on start to finish and every member passing through the shop would ask, “How’s Tiger doing?” or “Is Tiger winning?” It was just an almost foregone conclusion that he would finish on top of the leader board.

That’s kind of the reputation Marvel Studios has built since 2008 when it released Iron Man, the first entry in Phase One of its grand Marvel Cinematic Universe. With an amazing string of critical, fan, and box office hits, you just expect each new Marvel film to be terrific.

So when Eternals came out—the third film in Phase Four of the MCU following Black Widow and Shang-Chiyou just kind of expected it would be another home run. To give the film even more cred, Marvel brought in Chloe Zhao following her Best Picture and Director Academy Awards win for Nomadland to helm the film, who gets a screenplay credit as well. They also stacked the cast with a ton of stars and diversity. In fact, this is by far the most ethnically inclusive cast of any Marvel film, to the point that it almost feels like the filmmakers were going down a list and checking off to make sure everyone was represented.

So, when Eternals debuted as the lowest-rated Marvel film—and the first to be certified Rotten with a critics’ score of only 47%—you couldn’t help but wonder, “What went wrong?”

When it comes to movies, I like to make up my own mind. So while I mentally filed the bad reviews away, it wasn’t going to change my plans to see it when it debuted on Disney+ on January 12. There was a rather humorous and meta comment from one character who says, “DVD? It’s all about streaming now!” 

Probably like many of you, I’m not a Marvel super-fan, so I knew absolutely nothing about the comic-book roots of the Eternals characters featured in the film. For the film to be successful, though, it had to work for the uninitiated and serve to bring them into the fold, as well as provide the deeper layers of fan-service to the faithful.

For me, Eternals’ biggest problem is there is just too much. You’re trying to keep up with and learn about ten characters that are likely brand new to you. To add to the learning curve, they all have names that don’t exactly immediately imprint on your mind like Iron Man or Spider-Man. We’ve got Ajak, Sersi, Ikaris, Kingo, Sprite, Phastos, Makkari, Druig, Gilgamesh, and Thena. And when I’m spending mental energy thinking, “Who is that again? And what is their power?” you’ve probably missed a page in the “How to make a superhero movie” primer.

At one point, my wife said, “XXX just died. I feel like I should care more.” And that’s the other problem—with so many new faces and stories, you never really get the time to care about any of these characters. When Tony Stark died in Endgame it was wrenching because we’d cared about him over the course of numerous films and 13 years. With Eternals, it was almost a relief of, “Well, that’s one less person I have to keep up with.”

At 2 hours and 36 minutes, Eternals is long. Now, I don’t mind a long film, but when it feels long, that’s a problem. There are many parts through the middle that just kind of drag along. At one point, I got up to get a snack and hit pause and my family literally groaned when they saw it still had 41 minutes left. When you’re sitting there wondering, “When is this thing gonna end?” that’s another giant red flag.

One of the things Marvel has done so well is to feel like this is all part of a larger universe, and that everything fits in. While I realize this is the beginning-ish of a new Phase of the MCU, Eternals feels totally disconnected from the rest of the world. There are a couple of forced comments about who will lead the Avengers now and a reference to Thanos erasing half the population, but they’re almost “blink and you’ll miss it” throwaway remarks. 

Of course, Eternals has the requisite big, over-the-top, VFX-laden battles, some wide cinematic vistas, and some light-hearted moments, mostly provided by Kuail Nanjiani (Kingo), who I’m a big fan of since his movie The Big Sick, and his valet Karun (Harish Patel). 

The film opens with a very Star Wars-like text preamble trying to give the film some context but even this is a bit convoluted. Since this is literally the opening of the film, there’s no spoilers in sharing:

In the beginning . . .
. . . before the six Singularities and the dawn of creation, came the CELESTIALS. Arishem, the Prime Celestial, created the first sun and brought light into the universe. Life began, and thrived.

All was in balance. Until an unnatural species of predator emerged from deep space to feed on intelligent life—they were known as DEVIANTS. The universe was plunged into chaos.

To restore the natural order, Arishem sent ETERNALS—the immortal heroes from the planet Olympia—to eliminate the Deviants. Eternals had unyielding faith in Arishem until one mission, led by the Prime Eternal, Ajak, changed everything . . .

Disney+ offers the film in either its cinematic 2.39:1 aspect ratio (which will be preferred for projector owners with widescreens) or in IMAX Enhanced, where some scenes are presented in 1.78:1, which fills a traditional 16:9 screen. The Disney+ stream is encoded in Dolby Vision, along with HDR-10. Eternals was shot in 4.5K resolution, and this is sourced from a 4K digital intermediate.

Images are certainly clean, sharp, and noise-free but I never felt like I was getting that tack-sharp ultra-detail of the finest 4K transfers. There is plenty of detail to be sure, especially in closeups, but I was really convinced this was upconverted from a 2K source. There was an uptick in image quality when it cut to the enhanced IMAX images, whether due to the better cameras or IMAX’s DNR process I can’t say, but I felt the expanded height enhanced the scenes where it was used.

Night cityscapes always look stunning in HDR, with the bright, multi-colored lights dotted against a dark background, and shots of London look beautiful. At one point, the characters walk under a dark overpass and there are glowing white lights that have loads of intensity. There are also plenty of brightly lit outdoor scenes, with the golden sun radiating enough to make you squint. A walk through a rocky valley showed lots of texture and shadow detail in the crevices and hollows.

The characters’ powers are often manifested by glowing yellow-gold effects (eye lasers, bolt blasts, weapons) and these have a lot of vibrancy, especially when employed at night. There are also several scenes with really saturated red, such as lava, fires burning, or the glowing red lava-like pools of Arishem, which not only have a lot of intensity but also depth and a variety of shading. 

Sonically, the Dolby Atmos track is really engaging and entertaining, with lots of immersive moments both big and small. To be fair, this is one of the first films I’ve watched with a Trinnov Altitude processor I’m reviewing, so I’m sure having that in the system only added to the enjoyment. 

There are many moments where characters are running or flying across and all around the room, Deviants creeping and jumping around the back of the room and into corners, or things flying overhead and along the sides. During one scene, Ikaris unleashes some eye-blasts that you can hear traveling through the room and then searing into the side walls. 

I found dialogue to be mostly easy to understand, and there are a few scenes where the audio mix gets creative by having voices swirl around and overhead to taunt you, or to give a ton of added weight to Arishem’s voice by having it boom and echo through the room.

Even smaller moments have a lot of air and presence. There is a scene where a lot of fighting is happening way off in the distance, and you can hear these far-off sounds of yelling and gunfire. There are also moments where thunder rolls through the room, or there’s the gentle sound of rain falling, or the whistling of wind. 

Disney has often been slagged for producing anemic, bass-less soundtracks but I definitely didn’t find that to be the case. There are lots of moments where your subs will pressurize the room, and impacts and collisions have authoritative weight. An earthquake early on has tons of rumble and rattle with the sounds of objects shaking and falling all around the room. The Deviants also have a really throaty low-bassy growl to their sounds. Plus, any film that has Pink Floyd’s “Time” in Atmos during the opening—with the sounds of drums occurring at all points around the room—is definitely headed in the right direction.

Of course, the film has the now requisite Marvel mid- and end-credits scenes to “tease” upcoming events in the MCU. I’d like to say these scenes were enough to rally me and get me excited for the next chapters in the Eternals story, but sadly, they weren’t. 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | Images are clean, sharp, and noise-free but never feel like they have the tack-sharp ultra-detail of the finest 4K transfers, instead looking like they were upconverted from a 2K source.

SOUND | The Dolby Atmos track is engaging and entertaining, with lots of immersive moments both big and small, and even the smaller moments have a lot of air and presence.

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: The Book of Boba Fett

The Book of Boba Fett (2021)

review | The Book of Boba Fett

related review

recent reviews

Amazon Prime | All Watched Over by
Machines of Loving Grace

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

This new Disney+ series isn’t so much a sequel to The Mandalorian as it is an attempt to freshen up the Star Wars mythology

by Dennis Burger
December 30, 2021

Here’s what you need to know before dipping into The Book of Boba Fett, the first episode of which is now streaming on Disney+. First off, go back and watch the first two seasons of The Mandalorian if you haven’t already. Narratively, this new series by Jon Favreau follows pretty much straight on from that show and represents something of a fork in its narrative. But don’t confuse this with The Mandalorian Season 2.5. Favreau and team seem to be hellbent on keeping things from getting too stale, from falling into traps of the sort that snared fan-servicing but thematically hollow Star Wars offshoots like Rogue One. 

Favreau’s tale of an old bounty hunter stepping in and filling the void left by an old crime lord (namely, Jabba the Hutt) avoids the biggest sins of far too many stories set in the new and ever-expanding canon of Disney-era Star Wars in that it doesn’t make the Galaxy Far, Far Away feel like it could all fit within the walls of Pinewood Studios. He seems determined to make this universe feel larger, not smaller.

The first episode, directed by Robert Rodriguez, makes a lot of allusions to existing franchise mythology. But it doesn’t simply pull out Tusken Raiders, for example, and dangle them in front of you as if to say, “Hey, remember these weird donkey-braying mummy Bedouin you loved as a kid? Here’s a quick and cheap dopamine fix to buy us some goodwill for a bit.” The Book of Boba Fett borrows from the past when it needs to (from both established canon and the orphaned Legends series of books and comics) and charts a new path when it’s appropriate, striking exactly the right balance between nostalgia and novelty. 

None of this would work if Favreau didn’t fundamentally understand what makes Star Wars tick. And he proves again and again that he does indeed get it by breaking rules that seem almost sacrosanct and nonetheless getting away with it. That extends at times to even the structure of the story itself, which breaks from linear tradition and is all the better for it. If you’d informed me ahead of time that the bulk of this first episode would be told through a series of flashbacks, I would have replied, “That ain’t Star Wars!” And yet, somehow, magically, it is. 

That’s largely due to Favreau continuing to tinker with the franchise’s east-meets-west formula in interesting ways. He borrows liberally and unapologetically from so many of the classic films and TV shows that inspired the original films but he’s not mining the same veins over and over. Instead of The Man with No Name he pulls more from A Man Called Horse. Instead of Buck Rogers, he leans hard on the work of Ray Harryhausen. Instead of shogun we get . . . space ninjas?  Apparently, that’s a thing now? But again, it just works.

Even though the first episode is something of a narrative and thematic departure from The Mandalorian, there is understandably a lot of aesthetic and stylistic continuity. Like its forebear, The Book of Boba Fett is a pretty underlit show, and it seems to have been plopped into an HDR container mostly just to avoid the artifacts that still occasionally plague SDR streaming. You won’t spot many or any extremes of brightness here, although the expanded dynamic range does allow for a handful of incredibly low-lit scenes without any loss of depth or detail. And I didn’t spot a single instance of banding, moiré, or misplaced textures of the sort you can get when HEVC gets bit-starved.

The Dolby Atmos mix also follows the style of The Mandalorian, giving the environments and music room to breathe without being overbearing. Speaking of the music, Ludwig Göransson returns to deliver some themes and leitmotifs but the bulk of the score seems to have been composed and conducted by Joseph Shirley, who filled in some musical gaps in Season Two of Mando. Shirley’s work isn’t quite as funky or avant-garde as Göransson’s but it does fit the somewhat different mood of this series. 

With only one episode available out of a planned seven, it’s impossible to know if The Book of Boba Fett will live up to its potential once all is said and done. But it’s off to a heck of a good start.

Dennis Burger is an avid Star Wars scholar, Tolkien fanatic, and Corvette enthusiast who somehow also manages to find time for technological passions including high-end audio, home automation, and video gaming. He lives in the armpit of Alabama with his wife Bethany and their four-legged child Bruno, a 75-pound American Staffordshire Terrier who thinks he’s a Pomeranian.

PICTURE | You won’t spot many or any extremes of brightness here although HDR does allow for a handful of incredibly low-lit scenes without any loss of depth or detail.

SOUND | The Dolby Atmos mix follows the style of The Mandalorian, giving the environments and music room to breathe without being overbearing.

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Encanto

Encanto (2021)

review | Encanto

related reviews

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

Disney’s latest  is a tale of magic filled with beautiful, vibrant tropical colors that burst off the screen

by John Sciacca
December 27, 2021

I’m totally biased when it comes to Disney Animation. I have two daughters, and when Disney or Pixar releases a film, we’re going to watch it. That doesn’t mean I think they’re all great—it just means they don’t need to do a lot of marketing to get me on board. 

When there’s a movie all four of us can sit down, enjoy, and experience together, that’s saying something. (My five-and-a-half year old, Audrey, was very apprehensive about watching, though. The commercial has a “yellow three-headed dragon monster”—it’s actually Cerberus—that scared her, so she thought the movie was going to be about that. After lots of coaxing—and a nearby blanket she could quickly duck under if things got too scary—she decided she could be brave enough to give it a try.) So literally the moment I saw Encanto was available to watch on Disney+—in 4K with Dolby Vision and Dolby Atmos audio—I texted my wife and let her know we had our Friday night plans nailed down.

I was already all-in on watching the film, but what really had me interested was Lin-Manuel Miranda’s involvement, as he wrote eight original songs for Encanto (his second Disney Animation collaboration after writing songs for Moana). After Hamilton and In the Heights, Miranda has won me over with his catchy rapid-fire lyrics and layered, reference-dropping song-telling style. 

The film follows the Madrigal family, which lives in Columbia in an “Encanto”—a charmed or enchanted place—where a magical candle creates a sentient “Casita” (which means “little house”) for the family to live in, and a village grows around the house. As each member of the family reaches a certain age, a new magical door appears on the Casita, and when they open it, they’re gifted certain super-human abilities—super strength, super hearing, ability to heal, ability to grow flowers, etc.—which they use to help the villagers and continue the magic of the family. When it’s time to receive her gift, young Mirabel (Stephanie Beatriz) goes to open her door but it disappears, leaving her the only family who doesn’t have a gift, making her the odd one out, with her sisters, the perfect “golden child” Isabela (Diane Guerrero) and super-strong Luisa (Jessica Darrow). 

On the night the next Madrigal member, Antonio (Ravi Cabot-Conyers), is to receive his gift, Mirabel has a vision of the Casita crumbling and the candle’s flame being extinguished. When matriarch Abuela Alma (Maria Cecilia Botero) arrives and sees the Casita undamaged, she doesn’t believe Mirabel, causing Mirabel to investigate. She then stumbles across Uncle Bruno (John Lequizamo)—whose gift is having visions of the future—who has exiled himself from the community and whose name no one wants to utter (summed up in the very catchy song, “We don’t talk about Bruno-no-no-no”). When actual cracks start appearing in the Casita—and between family members—Mirabel knows she must do something to save the miracle, the family, and the village. 

Like any great piece of writing, Encanto touches on lots of issues and has different layers that will resonate with people in different ways, not just the usual this joke is for adults and this one is for kids. Whether you were the “golden child” and had to live up to the pressure of being perfect or were the family’s backbone everyone relied on or the outcast that seemingly didn’t fit in, Encanto has bits, moments, and characters that will ring true. 

There is the very obvious message of fitting in and finding your own talents and embracing your gifts and strengths whatever they are, and not judging your worth based on others. Also, not everyone’s life is as perfect as it may seem, and we all have our own struggles and pressures even when everything might look perfect on the outside (something that will hopefully resonate with all the young girls infected with the toxic Instagram culture). And ultimately, even though no family is perfect, we need to do our best to love them.

As mentioned, the Disney+ presentation is in 4K with Dolby Vision HDR. Taken from a true 4K digital intermediate, it looks gorgeous. Computer animation certainly lends itself to HDR and to delivering bright, vibrant, beautiful images, and Encanto has tropical colors that just burst off the screen. 

One of the things that really struck me was the fire effect, specifically around the candle that plays an important role in the film. There are a lot of scenes where you’re able to look at the candle flame, and the animation of the dance and flicker, the lighting, glowing effect, and shadows cast from the candle are just beautiful. The light slowly fading to different shades from the candle can be really tricky for a display, and there were a couple of moments where I noticed a bit of banding, but this might have been an animation style choice and not a streaming-video artifact. But, the lighting work in Encanto is just stunning.

Of course, with animation, the artists carefully scrutinize every frame, so focus is always perfect, with images always sharp and clear. They also pay close attention to every visual detail such as the small frays in rope, stitches in fabric, the texture of stone or tile, and literally individual grains of sand. Beyond the vibrant and lush tropical colors, the family’s doors as they gain their powers have inscriptions that glow a brilliant shade of gold that highlights the strength of the Dolby Vision HDR. (And did Bruno’s red chair remind anyone else of Morpheus’s chair from The Matrix . . ?) 

I wouldn’t call Encanto’s Dolby Atmos sound mix overly active but there are some nice moments of ambience that help to place us in the action, such as birds chirping or flying overhead, the sounds of bugs or wind, and then tile and stone cracking and shattering that spreads and expands up into the canopy of the ceiling and out into the room. The audio also opens up the listening environment with some cavernous echoes when appropriate, being drenched in a pouring rainstorm, or the spreading boom of thunder.  

The music is the sonic star of the Dolby Atmos soundtrack, and the songs are definitely catchy, with our family singing some of them even a couple of days later. The mix gives the voices space to spread across the front of the room and even up into the ceiling. You can better appreciate the layering during the ensemble numbers, though some of the rapid-fire lyrics (particularly in the opening song “The Family Madrigal”) can be a bit tricky to catch on the first go-round.

Your subwoofers don’t get called on a lot but they do fill in some deep percussion from the songs (particularly during Luisa’s “Surface Pressure”) and give some serious, tactile low end when things come crashing to the ground. 

With so many families gathered for the holidays, Encanto offers a wonderful opportunity to round everyone up in your home theater and share an experience. With a message that speaks to the strength of family, gorgeous images that will highlight your video display, and a catchy soundtrack, Encanto offers tantos razones to give it a watch. 

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | Computer animation lends itself to HDR and to delivering bright, vibrant, beautiful images, and Encanto has tropical colors that burst off the screen.

SOUND | The music is the sonic star of the Atmos soundtrack, and the mix gives the voices space to spread across the front of the room and even up into the ceiling.

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Review: Soul

Soul (2020)

review | Soul

recent reviews

Sign up for our monthly newsletter
to stay up to date on Cineluxe

The most adult Pixar film to date avoids getting bogged by its weighty themes, maintaining a childlike sense of wonder

by John Sciacca
December 26, 2020

Disney’s gift to families arrived on Disney+ yesterday in the form of Pixar’s 23rd feature-length film, Soul, which is arguably the largest title to debut on the streaming service without requiring the purchased premium access of the recent live-action Mulan remake. (Onward had a brief theatrical release before being moved to the streaming site.)

Soul tackles Pixar’s biggest, most complex, and heady adult ideas and themes to date. While other Pixar films have dealt with the death of a main character (notably the loss of a parent in Onward), here we get a version of both the afterlife and pre-existence—and I’d say despite the pleasing visuals (especially in the vibrant and colorful Great Before) and big-eyed cuteness of the ever-smiling new souls, it isn’t really a children’s movie at all. But the genius of Pixar films has always been that they are able to entertain and appeal to viewers across large age groups, and the jokes and themes here are certainly geared toward an older audience, such as what some of those sign-spinners are really up to, what happens to hedge-fund managers, and why the Knicks keep losing. Jazz—or “black improvisation music” as Joe Gardner’s (Jamie Foxx) father calls it—also plays a prominent role throughout the film, a musical genre that isn’t typically kid-friendly, and it also features “real,” poignant adult conversations between characters, such as the chat Joe has with his longtime barber Dez (Donnell Rawlings). 

You could consider Soul the final (?) film in director Pete Docter’s reverse life-cycle trilogy, which began with 2009’s Up, which focused on a person nearing the end of his life, followed by 2015’s Inside Out, which put us in the mind of a pre-teenager figuring out her emotions. With Soul, we actually roll back to pre-existence, discovering how people get their unique personality traits and find that “spark” that motivates them.

The movie begins with Joe, a part-time middle-school band instructor, getting hired on full-time at the school. While his mother, Libba (Phylicia Rashad), is thrilled at the prospect of him having a steady paycheck, insurance, and security instead of his gigging lifestyle, Joe feels it’s turning his back on his dream of being a jazz musician. When one of his old students, Curley (Questlove), calls him to see if he’s available to audition to play piano with the Dorothea Williams (Angela Bassett) Quartet that evening, Joe nails the try out and leaves on Cloud Nine, oblivious to everything going on around him. This leads to him walking into an open manhole, and, well, coming around as a soul ascending towards the great white light of the Great Beyond. But Joe isn’t willing to accept that he has died on the night of his big break, so he fights to get back to his body on earth. 

And that is just the first 11 minutes of the movie. From there we transition to the Great Before—rebranded as the You Seminar—where mentors work with new souls that are given unique and individual personalities to prepare them for life on Earth. (One soul proclaims, “I’m a manipulative megalomaniac who’s intensely opportunistic.”)  Another group of souls is sent to become self-absorbed, causing one of the counselors to say, “We really should stop sending so many people through that pavilion.” 

The final step in a soul receiving its full personality—and getting its Earth pass—is for it to find its “spark,” or that thing that drives them. Joe is assigned to Mentor 22 (Tina Fey), who has been stuck as a new soul for years with no desire to go to Earth, having broken previous mentors such as Mother Theresa, Gandhi, Abraham Lincoln, and Mohammed Ali. 

With the help of Moonwind (Graham Norton), an astral traveler who sails about The Zone, a place between the spiritual and physical, in a tie-dye-sailed ship listening to Bob Dylan and helping lost souls find their way, 22 and Joe make it back to Earth, but not exactly in the way the Joe is hoping. I thought the film was going to take a Steve Martin/Lily Tomlin All of Me turn but it doesn’t. Without spoiling, I’ll say Joe comes back in a way where he can still communicate with 22 but with no one else.

The movie has three distinct animation styles defining the Great Beyond, the Great Before, and life on Earth. The Beyond is rendered in very contrasty black and white with just the color of the souls headed towards the light (a scene that reminded me of Carousel from Logan’s Run, whether intentional or not), whereas the Great Before is vibrant, filled with glowing blue, pink, and purple pastels and almost neon-tube drawings with things glowing bright around outlined edges. Earth is hyper-realistic. with a more muted, natural color scheme. 

Image quality is fantastic and reference-quality, making Soul beautiful and just pleasing to look at. While the Great Before has colors that leap off the screen (especially in Dolby Vision), it’s the scenes on Earth that really show off Pixar’s animation prowess, with fine micro details visible in literally anything you choose to focus on. The texture, layering, and fading colors in street graffiti, the floor of the barbershop and look of Dez’s shoes, the distress in iron railings, the sweat that appears on musicians’ faces after a long gig, the variety of people walking around the streets of New York, or the reflection off a glossy piano lid revealing the workings inside. Remembering that every . . . single . . . pixel of detail, every micro imperfection, every scratch and nick, every reflection, every subtle lighting effect have all been painstakingly created by choice takes appreciation to the next level.

You can also really appreciate the choices the Pixar artists make in how they animate different things. While they’ve settled on the look of people, other items like buildings, backgrounds, and furniture get near-photo-realistic detail. Other things like photos of jazz greats in a stairwell, or the stage at the club, land somewhere in between. 

As mentioned, jazz is a prominent, recurring theme throughout the film, and the Dolby Atmos audio does a great job presenting it, especially when Joe is really grooving and in-the-zone, where music swirls overhead and around the room. Voices in the Great Before are echoey, while the street sounds and cacophony of New York sound appropriately overwhelming. There are also plenty of nice subtle moments throughout, such as the flatter, low-roof sound of music in the Half Note, the clack of tracks aboard the subway, or the buzz overhead as Joe stands under a neon light. Most important, dialogue is always clear and perfectly intelligible. 

Soul is a deep story that actually takes a bit of unpacking, and it looks so good you’ll likely want to revisit it, where you’ll likely discover plenty of new things to appreciate. Finding out what things make a life and learning to enjoy the simple pleasures and experiences it has to offer is the real heart of Soul, and this is another win for Pixar.

Probably the most experienced writer on custom installation in the industry, John Sciacca is co-owner of Custom Theater & Audio in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, & is known for his writing for such publications as Residential Systems and Sound & Vision. Follow him on Twitter at @SciaccaTweets and at johnsciacca.com.

PICTURE | Image quality is fantastic and reference-quality, making Soul beautiful and just pleasing to look at.

SOUND | The Atmos audio does a great job presenting the jazz soundtrack, especially when the lead character is really grooving and in-the-zone, where music swirls overhead and around the room. 

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

I Hope Marvel Never Makes Another WandaVision

I Hope Marvel Never Makes Another Wandavision

I Hope Marvel Never Makes Another WandaVision

the MCU on Cineluxe

related articles

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

Coming from history’s most successful superhero franchise, you’d except to see a sequel to this Disney+ series—that would be a really bad idea

by Dennis Burger
March 11, 2021

As I’ve said before (so much that regular readers are probably getting sick of hearing it), Captain America: The Winter Soldier changed everything for the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It showed us how MCU movies could rise above the tropes and trappings of superhero cinema, and it gave the movies that followed it the freedom to play around with genre in interesting ways. If Winter Soldier hadn’t worked and hadn’t connected with audiences, I don’t think we would have WandaVision today. I just don’t think Marvel would have had the courage to make it.

But WandaVision changes everything yet again, showing that you can take the single most mainstream intellectual property in the world and get abstract with it. You can experiment; you can out-bizarre Twin Peaks and still hang onto your fanboy audience, many of whom latch onto the MCU for no other reason than the wish-fulfillment/power-trip aspect of it all. 

Well, you can hang onto a lot of them. I have to admit, geeky though I may be, I’ve pretty much divorced myself from geek culture since the release of Star Wars: The Last Jedi—mostly due to the toxicity of it all, but also because the loudest contingent of fantasy/sci-fi fans on the internet no more understands the properties they love to wax neck-beardedly about than my American Staffordshire Terrier understands quantum chromodynamics. 

The few discussions I’ve seen about WandaVision, now that it’s over, frustrate and infuriate me in equal measure because here we have a story that cuts straight to the heart of what it means to be human in a way no film or series of any genre has in ages, and the only things the Comic-Con crowd wants to discuss are why Mephisto didn’t make an appearance or whether Agatha’s rabbit familiar, Señor Scratchy, is secretly her son Nicholas Scratch from the comic books. 

All fun topics to talk about, mind you, as frivolous as they may be. But can we take a breather from the soap-opera discussions to focus on what made WandaVision legitimately good? Can we appreciate that the company known for making movies about dudes fighting robots in their pajamas had the courage to tell a story in which the primary antagonists are grief, pain, cognitive dissonance, and consequences? And not physical manifestations thereof, but the actual human emotions?

Can we maybe take a breather from geeking out over the big action set-pieces to appreciate the fact that the biggest knock-down, drag-out battle in the finale was won not with fists or laser eyes, but a philosophical argument centered on the Ship of Theseus? Can we talk about the fact that, as weird as the first half of WandaVision was, it avoided the biggest sins of Twin Peaks by knowing when to back off the eccentricities, lest they lose their value?

I’m not saying WandaVision was perfect. I found it more than a bit disappointing when the penultimate episode overexplained too many of the series’ earlier abstractions, assuming I suppose that some of its audience may not have been able to connect the dots for themselves. But such slip-ups are few and far between, which is surprising for a show that works on so many levels. 

WandaVision is a story about struggling with grief and the toll that can take on those around us. It’s also a meditation on our weird relationship with media—how we influence it and how it influences us, both overtly and subliminally. It’s a clever examination of shifting cultural norms and how what we accept as normal today is as much a manipulated affectation as any of the tropes of the past. 

The series’ strengths lie in its uniqueness. And you could point to previous films it resembles in the most obvious of ways, such as Pleasantville and The Truman Show, but such similarities are mostly superficial (except, of course, for the latter’s framing of tragedy disguised as comedy, which this show appropriates with devastating effectiveness). WandaVision is, of all its references and call-backs, its own thing, which is why I’m worried it’s going to be used as a template, now that it has proven successful. 

I’m already seeing fans start to beg for a second season, and Marvel’s suits are being coy in their responses—and that terrifies me. As a lifelong fan of these characters—one who’s smitten with how they’ve been interpreted for screens large and small—I obviously want to see their stories continued. I’m as invested as could be. But I want to see Paul Bettany and Lizzie Olsen portraying Vision and the Scarlet Witch in new stories, told in new ways, not awkwardly fumbling around with attempts at capturing lighting in a bottle.

WandaVision was perhaps the most satisfying and self-contained narrative I’ve seen unfold in ages. And now it’s over; it’s done; there’s no more of this story to tell. But that doesn’t mean someone won’t try to replicate it. And if you need evidence of that, just look at the number of new streaming services that have come out in the past year with meaningless “+” symbols stapled onto the end of their names. 

Yes, yes, I know—a streaming service and a TV series are not the same thing, but Hollywood has a knack for aping what works without understanding why it works. When Disney+ launched back in 2019, that binary operator at the end of its name actually meant something. It was shorthand for Disney + Pixar + Star Wars + Marvel + National Geographic. What the hell does Apple TV+ connote—much less Paramount+, the new name for the streaming service formerly known as CBS All Access? Paramount + what, exactly? 

In keeping with that entertainment-industry tradition, it stands to reason we’ll eventually see at least a few feeble attempts at replicating the self-referential, heartfelt-story-framed-as-classic-sitcom container in which WandaVision was delivered, with no thought given to what that device actually meant in the context of this story. 

The most I can hope for is that Marvel doesn’t attempt to scrape this barrel again, and certainly not with these characters, because wishing for anything more than that would be like Charlie Brown, facing that football once more, hoping beyond hope that Lucy doesn’t yank it away at the last second.

Dennis Burger is an avid Star Wars scholar, Tolkien fanatic, and Corvette enthusiast who somehow also manages to find time for technological passions including high-end audio, home automation, and video gaming. He lives in the armpit of Alabama with his wife Bethany and their four-legged child Bruno, a 75-pound American Staffordshire Terrier who thinks he’s a Pomeranian.

Sign up for our monthly newsletter to stay up to date on Cineluxe

© 2023 Cineluxe LLC

Scroll to top

sign up for our newsletter

receive a monthly recap of everything that’s new on Cineluxe